Disable Preloader

difference between ball mill and rod mill grinding mechanism


    2.1 Breakage mechanisms in a ball mill 22 2.2 First order reaction model applied to milling 24 2.3 Grinding rate versus particle size for a given ball diameter 25 2.4 Cumulative breakage function versus relative size 28 2.5 Predicted variation of S i values with ball diameter for dry grinding of quartz 31

  • Difference Between Sag Mill vs Ball Millmech4study

    Today we will learn about difference between sag mill vs ball mill A mill is a machine by which solid or hard materials are broken into smaller pieces by means of grinding crushing or cutting This commutation is an essential part of many processes Various kinds of mills are there with which different material processing takes place.

  • The difference between ball mill and rod mill

    Difference Ball mill and rod mill is mainly for grinding grain size of not more than 60mm of various hardness ores and other materials The resulting product after ball mill grinding its range of variation for a particle size is below 1.5mm and 1.5mm.

  • Ball Mills vs Rod Mills

    Rods in place weigh approximately 400 pounds per cu ft and balls in place approximately 300 pounds per cu ft. Thus quantitatively less material can progress through the voids in the rod mill grinding media than in the ball mill and the path of the material is more confined.

    Estimated Reading Time 5 mins

  • size reduction laws involved in size reduction

    size reduction laws involved in size reduction application mills 1 SIZE REDUCTION Size reduction is the process of reducing the particle size of a substance to a finer state of subdivision to smaller pieces to coarse particles or to powder Size reduction process is also referred to as comminution and grinding.

  • Ball Mill

    Ball mill and rod mill is very good for grinding ore into fine dust particles However improved efficiency large scale mining projects including the coordination of performance improvement and energy costs using a rod from the ball mill has several advantages Ball mill even if it is used more often however plant the rod is a better

  • Ball Mill Operating principles components Uses

    The balls which could be of different diameter occupy 3050 of the mill volume and its size depends on the feed and mill size The large balls tend to break down the coarse feed materials and the smaller balls help to form fine product by reducing void spaces between the balls Ball mills grind material by impact and attrition.

  • Grinding Mills and Their TypesIspatGuru

    Grinding mills are size reductions machines that often follow crushers in the processes where finer products are desired after crushing Different grinding machines are usually named as mills for example rod mills ball mills and attrition mills Because of the name verb milling is also been used as a synonym for grinding.

  • What s the difference of Ball mill SAG mill AG mill

    Attrition mill is a type of grinding mill by kinds of media to crush lump to powder like substances The impact can be rock on rock such as in an Autogenous Grinding AG mill rock and a small ball charge 10 used in Semi Autogenous Grinding SAG mills balls of various sizes in Ball Mills and less commonly these days steel rods in Rod Mills.

  • Ball Mill Cement Mill Grinding Mill Rotary Kiln Cement

    Ball Mill Cement Mill Grinding Mill Rotary Kiln Cement Kiln Lime Kiln Supplier Henan ZK Corp already has been growing up to a comprehensive company with strong ability of the whole system researching and designing on process technology and equipment manufacturing in the fields of building materials mining metallurgy environmental protection etc.

  • Small Scale Tests to Characterise Ore Grindibility

    to that of the ball mill test as follows It is common to observe a difference between the rod mill and ball mill values for a given ore type These differences may be caused by a variation in ore hardness by size 12.5mm for RWI and 3.35mm for BWI and/or grain size properties The Bond rod mill work index is used to calculate the power

  • MEI s Barry Wills Are rod and ball mills set to become

    This was the provocative question I asked delegates at Comminution 10 during the final summing up of the conference At the beginning of the 20th century the advent of rod and ball mills led to the demise of stamp mills and rod and ball mills then dominated 20th century grinding circuits.

  • Tips for Grinding and Dispersion Blog Hockmeyer

    Tips for Grinding and Dispersion One of the keys to proper milling is making a good premix This is also one of the most neglected processes in the particle reduction industry The better the dispersion before taking the product over to the mill the more productive the milling cycle will become.

  • The Difference Structure between Overflow Rod Mill and

    3 When the rod mill is used for primary grinding the product particle sizes are 3 1mm The production capacity of rod mill is larger than that of the ball mill with the same specifications While the rod mill is used for fine grinding the ground and crushed particle sizes are 0.5mm.

  • Explore further

    Ball Mills vs Rod Mills911metallurgist10 Ways to Improve the Grinding Efficiency of Your Ball MillminingpediaCalculate and Select Ball Mill Ball Size for Optimum Grinding911metallurgistTrunnion Bearing Assembly Ball Mill Rod Mill911metallurgistGrinding MillsCommon Types911metallurgistRecommended to you based on what s popular Feedback

  • The essential grindCIM

    The Bond Ball Mill Work Index remains today as the only tool used for ball mill scale up design For an only nominally not at all materially modified update on its use for industrial mill sizing see Selection of Rod Mills Ball Mills Pebble Mills and Regrind Mills Rowland C A Jr 1982 Chapter 23 Design and Installation of

  • Size Reduction Equipment

    1 Hammer Mills 2 Rolling Compression Mills a Bowl Mills b Roller Mills 3 Attrition Mills 4 Tumbling Mills a Rod Mills b Ball Mill Pebble Mill c Tube Mills Compartment Mills A primary crusher operates on run of mine material accepting anything that comes from the mine face and breaking into mm 6 10 in .

  • Mechanisms Lead Screws And Ball Screws Hackaday

    Mechanisms Lead Screws And Ball Screws Translating rotary motion to linear motion is a basic part of mechatronic design Take a look at the nearest 3D printer or CNC router at least the

  • A comparative study on the effects of dry and wet

    Chapman et al 2013 compared the effects of using different circuits HPGR dry rod mill wet and cone crusher dry rod mill wet on the flotation of base metal sulfides They indicated that apart from the grinding environment HPGR could produce finer particles than a cone crusher This difference was higher in the fully dry system.

  • What s the Difference Between SAG Mill and Ball Mill

    Grinding mill machine is an essential part of many industrial processes there are mainly five types of mills to cover more than 90 materials size reduction applications Do you the difference between the ball mill rod mills SAG mill tube mill pebble mill In the previous article I made a comparison of ball mill and rod mill Today we

  • What are the differences between ball mill and rod mill

    The rod of diameter from 50 to 100 mm is often used as the grinding medium and the filling rate of rod mill is 35 to 45 while filling rate of ball mill is 40 to 50 Rod is mainly made of several materials A High carbon steel

  • Difference Between Ag Sag Ball Mill Rod Mill

    Sme 2009 Impact On Grinding Mill Design And Recent breakage tests do not include ball mill grinding dataased on the 2009 cim paper starkey and s 2009 the ratio of sag to ball mill grindability is an important factor in achieving a reliable sag mill circuit design because that ratio reveals the best and most practical split for sag and ball mill energy for the ore being tested.

  • Grinding Mills and Pulverizers Selection Guide Types

    Video credit shsbjq CC BY SA 4.0 Specifications Important specifications when selecting grinding mills and pulverizers include The size of the mill can range from pilot/lab to production e.g 3.5 to 1600 cu ft Feed size material and hardness of feed must be considered Output size ranges Mills can handle dry or wet input or both Mills operate in batches or continuously.

  • The Difference Between The Ball Mill And Rod Mill

    difference between sag mill and ball mill difference between rod mill and ball mill Rock crusher for saledifference between rod mill and ball mill difference between rod mill and ball mill Learn More difference between rod mill and ball mill Difference between FAG and SKF Bearings

  • Comparing Used Ball Mills Vs Used Rod Mills

    If you need to grind mining media down to fine particles than a ball mill is recommended but if the material is large consider a rod mill for the heavy duty grinding For a huge selection of high quality used mining equipment visit Am King to find great deals on used ball mills rod mills crushing equipment and grinding equipment.


    Both ball mills and rod mills have been used for grinding ores or the like such a mill normally being a rotating cylinder containing a number of balls or rods formed of steel usually special alloy steels which crush and comminute the ore between them or against the side of the mill or perhaps the end thereof.


    Both ball mills and rod mills have been used for grinding ores or the like such a mill normally being a rotating cylinder containing a number of balls or rods formed of steel usually special alloy steels which crush and comminute the ore between them or against the side of the mill or perhaps the end thereof.

  • Visual Encyclopedia of Chemical Engineering

    Air Swept Pulverizer The particle feed is mixed with air as it is fed into the mill inlet 1 The beater plates 2 support the hammers 3 and distribute the particles around the periphery of the grinding chamber The hammers grind the solid against the liner 4 of the grinding chamber The beater plates rotate between 1600 and 7000 rpm

  • The difference between ball mill and rod millFodamon

    Grinding equipment widely used in concentrators is ball mill and rod mill The two have similarities in shape and grinding principles but there are also differences in structure performance and use This article analyzes their similarities and differences from seven aspects and tells you how to choose ball mill and rod mill.

  • Benefits of Used Grinding EquipmentEzineArticles

    Rod mills are quite similar to ball mills but use long steel rods instead of small balls for the grinding media Steel rods grind the ore by tumbling within the mill and the rods tumble and spin in roughly parallel alignments simulating a series of roll crushers Since a rod mill doesn t cascade it can be operated at a lower peripheral speed

  • difference between rod mill and ball mill

    difference between ball mill rod millveronaschoolhouse Oct 06 2016 Rod Mill Rod Mill Suppliers and Manufacturers at difference between ball mill rod mill difference between ball mill rod mill offers 19646 rod mill products About 10 of these are mine mill 2 are milling cutter and 1 are grinding

  • 7 Differences Between Ball Mill and Rod MillXinhai

    The rod mill usually adopts the steel bar with a diameter of 50 100mm as the grinding medium while the ball mill often uses steel ball as the grinding medium The difference on grinding medium is the main difference between the ball mill and rod mill There is point to point contact between the ball mill with the steel ball while there is

  • SAG Mill TestingTest Procedures to Characterize Ore

    mill As such primary ball mills should be designed with the rod mill work index and single stage ball mills should be with both the rod mill and ball mill indices This is because it is common to observe a difference sometimes significant between the rod mill and ball mill index values for a given ore type McKen Verret Williams 2006 On

  • Ball MillsMineral Processing Metallurgy

    Grinding Rod or Ball Mill TYPE D Has single weld triple flanged construction which means the shell is furnished in two sections flanged and bolted in the center All flanges are double welded as well as steel head to shell note design Tumbling Mill Rod or Ball Mill TYPE E Has quadruple flanged construction.


    Images from 911metallurgist

    Ball Mill Capacity vs Rod Mill CapacityUntil recently many operators have believed that one particular type of grinding mill had greater efficiency and resulting capacity than some otherBall vs Rod Mill ConversionThe correct grinding mill depends so much upon the particular ore being treated and the product desired that a mill must have maximum flexibilityBall Mill Trunnion and Mill Grate DischargeThe overflow type is more commonly used as it is lower in first cost These mills have large trunnion openings which allow high circulating loads tBall Mill Rod Mill LinersThe head and shell liners for Ball Rod Mills can be furnished of 1 Decolloy 2 Hard White Iron 3 Electric Steel 4 Chrome Moly Steel 5 MangBall Mill Grinding CircuitEven though many ores require fine grinding for maximum recovery most ores liberate a large percentage of the minerals during the first pass throuQuotation on A Ball Mill Price Or A Rod Mill PriceWhen requesting a quotation on a Ball Rod Mill it is requested that you include the following information 1 Type of mill Type A is standard Difference Between A Rod Mill and Ball MillRod Mills has a very define and narrow discharge product size range Feeding a Rod Mill finer rocks will greatly impact its tonnage while not signiRapid Discharge Grinding Ball MillHigh capacity low cost grinding wet or dry Simple efficient dependable eliminate fines slimes Write for Bulletin RAPID DISCHARGE MILL

  • Milling vs Grinding What s the Difference Monroe

    Milling is a machining process that involves the use of a milling machine to remove material from a workpiece Milling machines feature cutting blades that rotate while they press against the workpiece The workpiece is secured in place so that it doesn t rotate or otherwise rotate During operation though the milling machine will press a

  • GrindabilityMinerallurgy

    The low efficiency of grinding equipment in terms of the energy actually used to break the ore particles is a common feature of all types of mills but there are substantial differences between various designs Some machines are constructed in such a way that much energy is absorbed in the component parts and is not available for breaking.

  • Rod mills how they functionMine Engineer

    The rods grind the ore by tumbling within the the mill similar to the grinding balls in a ball mill To prevent the conditions leading to rod charge tangling the length to diameter ratio is maintained at 1.4 to 1.6 Rod mills accept feed up to about 50 mm 2 in and produce a product in the size range of 3000 to 270 mm –4 to –35 mesh .

  • What are the Differences Between Dry and Wet Type Ball

    2 According to the overall economic perspective of ball mill grinding Wet grinding is generally used in mineral processing because the wet ball mill has the advantages of strong materials adaptability continuous production large grinding ratio easy to adjust the fineness of the milled products and it is widely used at present.

  • Grinding MillsBlogger

    MATHEMATICS OF GRINDING Critical Speed The Critical Speed for a grinding mill is defined as the rotational speed where centrifugal forces equal gravitational forces at the mill shell s inside surface.This is the rotational speed where balls will not fall away from the mill s shell Mills are driven in practice at speeds of 50 90 of critical speed the choice being influenced by economic

  • MINE LINERSMagotteaux

    required grinding mechanism Three main categories of grinding mechanisms can be highlighted 1 IMPACT The mechanism of reducing the big rocks is crushing which requires impacts Either by impacting of grinding balls on the rocks SAG mill or by interaction between rocks on the one side and mill shell and toe of the grinding charge on the

  • Comparison of energy efficiency between ball mills and

    Nowadays ball mills still dominate secondary grinding applications but are increasingly in competition with closed circuit AG/SAG mill circuits and stirred mills Napier Munn et al 1996 At product sizes finer than 80 passing 75 μm the efficiency of ball mill grinding rapidly decreases.

    Cited by 64